Delivering Health Care By Drone



Delivering Health Care By Drone

By Roy Smythe*

“We may very well stand at one of those decisive turning points in history that separate whole eras from each other.  For contemporaries entangled, as we are, in the inexorable demands of daily life, the dividing lines between eras may be hardly visible when crossed; only after people stumble over them do the lines grow into wall which irretrievably shut off the past.”

-Hannah Arendt

I once asked a clinical colleague to describe what it had been like working as a trainee with a world-famous surgeon.

His response was surprising, and troubling – “Oh… he’s brilliant and talented, of course, but to be honest – he’s dangerous.  He has become more or less indifferent to patient suffering, and even death – I guess because he has seen so much of it.”

 

Although infrequent, this type of desensitization, or inurement, unfortunately does occur in clinical settings - whereby health care workers that are constantly exposed to suffering become “numbed” to it over time.

Hannah Arendt, the German-American philosopher, coined the term “banality of evil” in her New Yorker series covering the Nazi war criminal trial of Adolph Eichmann – suggesting that blind allegiance to authority can lead to indifference to suffering.  Although she was aggressively criticized by many for implying an apology for the Third Reich’s role in the Holocaust, those investigating the topic (most notably Stanley Milgram in his experiments illustrating that college students, given the instructions to shock others by an authority figure will do so repeatedly) have supported her theory.

Despite the fact that desensitization, and the “Milgram” effect are real, what I am really concerned about in health care at this particular “decisive turning point in history” is neither of these – what worries me is “distance.”

Could the use of technologies that distance health care providers from the first-hand experience of the suffering of those they care for (such as telemedicine platforms and other forms of “virtual visits” or self-care tools) lead to a collective “stumbling over lines” with unfortunate consequences?  On one side of these lines is empathy and understanding of the nature of suffering, and on the other, a loss of that perspective.

I recently spoke with Dr. Eric Cassell – a pioneer in the development of the specialty of Palliative Care.  He wrote a landmark article published in the New England Journal of Medicine in 1982, entitled “The Nature of Suffering and the Goals of Medicine,” and later edited a well-respected textbook by the same name.  We discussed both the possibility that technology could increasingly distance providers from suffering, and the fact that many physicians are “burning out” in a time when technology should actually be making their jobs easier.

“They are related,” he said. “The problem that physicians have now is not that they get too close to their patients, but that they do not get close enough… The suffering have special therapeutic needs, and those aren’t met by technology alone.”

Dr. Rushika Fernandapulle, the co-founder and CEO of Iora Health, a company that is growing a new model for primary care delivery leveraging high tech and high touch, shared his thoughts.

“The thing that heals people is relationships – the problem is that technology has the ability to actually facilitate relationships, but it can also get in the way of them.”

Karl Marlantes’ book about his experiences in Vietnam as a young soldier, “What it is Like to Go to War” examines the social and psychological consequences of fighting, killing and returning from those experiences, and provides an interesting analogy.  He asserts that the contemporary use of drones and cruise missiles, and the lack of subsequent exposure to the suffering and damage that these weapons cause – may have important unintended consequences.

“Death becomes an abstraction, except for those at the receiving end,” he says. “What is at stake is not only the psyche of each young fighter, but our humanity… the chances for transformational psychological experiences are decreased enormously when you wage war with all the comforts of home.  You have no way of knowing if you are in the sacred space of Mars and death, or coming home from it.”

Mars was the Roman god of war, and the Romans believed that Mars sanctioned war only as a means to achieve peace.  In the spirit of this ancient viewpoint, Marlantes implies that for one to “enter the Temple of Mars” that he must understand fully (experience) the consequences of his actions, and only seek war as a means to more humane ends.  Although the latter may be achieved with war from a distance, the former simply cannot.

The adoption and deployment of next generation technologies made possible by the digital revolution – those that move the locus of care closer to the patient, and “extend” the care capabilities of providers in a number of ways will be absolutely essential to improve the delivery of care.

However, as we use these new tools, let us take care to not allow them to create “walls difficult to traverse” between those that are providing care, and those that are suffering.  Let us continue to immerse ourselves in the nature of suffering of the diseases we treat, as well as the suffering that is often created by our efforts to treat them.  We must avoid, at all costs, simply delivering health care by drone.

Roy Smythe currently is the Chief Medical Officer for Valence Health, a Chicago-based health care consulting, services and operating company that seeks to facilitate the ability of providers of care to manage medical and financial risk. He was previously the Chief Medical Officer at AVIA, a provider-led health care technology accelerator. He is also Chief Executive Officer of HX360, an AVIA / HIMSS (Health Information Management and Systems Society) co-developed initiative, working at the interface between technology, process and structure in health care. He has enjoyed a long career in patient care – with time on staff at the University of Pennsylvania, The University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center and Baylor Scott & White Healthcare. 

Source: forbes.com

 



Technology
Post Author

Sokratis

Email: sokratis@armynow.net

Posts written: 70

With us since: 24.12.2020

Comments (73)

comment

http://slkjfdf.net/ - Jopiheipn <a href="http://slkjfdf.net/">Abahizaw</a> hgf.nmei.channel4society.com.tkc.qx http://slkjfdf.net/

comment

http://slkjfdf.net/ - Atadawel <a href="http://slkjfdf.net/">Atehpab</a> xxz.tnhb.channel4society.com.oku.lh http://slkjfdf.net/

comment

https://oscialipop.com - overnight cialis delivery Qulpgn Buy Propecia And Minoxidil Mgryot <a href=https://oscialipop.com>buy cialis online usa</a> Cxzvog stapes https://oscialipop.com - buy cialis online 20mg Jntzuh review viagra vs cialis

comment

Channel4Society <a href="http://www.gi039795g8x6u96h0pbijsj6xo8k2c45s.org/">acwjsqbexe</a> [url=http://www.gi039795g8x6u96h0pbijsj6xo8k2c45s.org/]ucwjsqbexe[/url] cwjsqbexe http://www.gi039795g8x6u96h0pbijsj6xo8k2c45s.org/

comment
Toggle Replies Reply
Cialis  2022-04-08, 4mos ago

cialis .uk http://cialiscnd.com/

comment
Toggle Replies Reply
Cialis  2022-04-08, 4mos ago

brand cialis 20 mg http://cialiscnd.com/

comment
Toggle Replies Reply
Cialis  2022-04-08, 4mos ago

cialis 5mg no prescription http://cialiscnd.com/

comment
Toggle Replies Reply
Cialis  2022-04-08, 4mos ago

does cialis shrink the prostate http://cialiscnd.com/

comment

cialis 36 hours <a href=" http://cialiscnd.com/# ">cialisonline</a> side effects of cialis and grapefruits

comment

cialis duration <a href=" http://cialiscnd.com/# ">buy cialis without prescription</a> cialis side effects

comment

clomid coupons <a href=" http://clomidfast.site/# ">buy clomid online without prescription</a> clomid purchase online

comment

clomid online cheap <a href=" https://clomiden.fun/# ">where to buy clomid</a> cost of clomid

comment

clomid 2020 <a href=" http://clomidfast.site/# ">where to buy clomid</a> clomid 50 mg

comment

where can i buy clomiphene <a href=" http://clomidus.store/# ">purchase clomiphene</a> clomid purchase

comment

clomid pills <a href=" http://clomidus.store/# ">clomid 100mg</a> clomid online

comment

buy clomid <a href=" http://clomidus.store/# ">clomid coupon</a> generic for clomid

comment

clomid pills <a href=" http://clomidfast.site/# ">clomid purchase online</a> clomid generic name

comment

clomid tablet <a href=" https://clomiden.fun/# ">clomiphene generic</a> order clomid

comment

clomid 100 mg tablet <a href=" https://clomiden.fun/# ">clomid online</a> clomid pills

comment

purchase clomid <a href=" https://clomiden.fun/# ">purchase clomid online</a> buy clomid online no prescription

comment

clomid <a href=" http://clomidus.store/# ">clomid 100mg</a> purchase clomid online

comment

clomid purchase online <a href=" https://clomiden.fun/# ">clomid online cheap</a> clomid canada

comment

doxycycline 100mg capsules <a href=" http://doxycyclineus.site/# ">buy doxycycline hyclate 100mg without a rx</a> online doxycycline

comment

doxycycline order online <a href=" https://doxycyclineen.shop/# ">doxycycline tetracycline</a> buy doxycycline without prescription

comment

prednisone 20 mg tablet price http://prednisoneen.store/

comment

prednisone canada prescription http://prednisonefast.site/

comment

prednisone 5mg over the counter http://prednisonefast.site/

comment

10 mg prednisone https://prednisoneus.shop/

comment

prednisone 10mg buy online http://prednisonefast.site/

comment

generic prednisone tablets http://prednisonefast.site/

comment

otc prednisone cream http://prednisonefast.site/

comment

prednisone 5 mg brand name https://prednisoneus.shop/

comment

prednisone online paypal http://prednisonefast.site/

comment

prednisone 40 mg https://prednisoneus.shop/

comment

prednisone 475 http://prednisoneen.store/

comment

prednisone for sale http://prednisoneen.store/

comment

buy prednisone no prescription http://prednisoneen.store/

comment

prednisone 40 mg daily https://prednisoneus.shop/

comment

prednisone cream http://prednisonefast.site/

comment

online prednisone 5mg http://prednisonefast.site/

comment

prednisone 5 mg cheapest http://prednisonefast.site/

comment

prednisone 50 mg tablet canada http://prednisonefast.site/

comment

medicine prednisone 5mg http://prednisonefast.site/

comment

prednisone 2 5 mg https://prednisoneus.shop/

comment

buy prednisone 20mg without a prescription best price https://prednisoneus.shop/

comment

cost of prednisone 40 mg http://prednisoneen.store/

comment

prednisone 10 mg online https://prednisoneus.shop/

comment

prednisone 4 mg daily https://prednisoneus.shop/

comment

prednisone online for sale http://prednisoneen.store/

comment

clomiphene for sale <a href=" https://clomiden.fun/# ">clomid generic name</a> clomid prescription

comment

generic clomid <a href=" http://clomidus.store/# ">cost of clomid</a> clomid medication

comment

clomid order online <a href=" https://clomiden.fun/# ">buy clomid 50mg</a> clomid for sale

comment

clomid medication <a href=" http://clomidfast.site/# ">clomid canada</a> clomid order online

comment

doxycycline mono <a href=" https://doxycyclinemst.com/# ">doxycycline tetracycline</a> where can i get doxycycline

comment

azithromycin amoxicillin <a href=" https://amoxilmst.com/# ">purchase amoxicillin 500 mg</a> buying amoxicillin online

comment

online ed meds <a href=" http://drugsfast.store/# ">prescription drugs without doctor approval</a> generic viagra without a doctor prescription prescription drugs online without doctor https://drugsus.shop/ generic viagra without a doctor prescription

comment

ivermectin products <a href=" https://stromectol.company/# ">is stromectol over the counter</a> ivermectin how to buy

comment

prednisone 20 mg tablet price <a href=" https://prednisonemrt.com/# ">prednisone 2 5 mg</a> prednisone over the counter australia

comment
Toggle Replies Reply
Cialis  2022-05-06, 3mos ago

cialis coupon walmart <a href=" https://cialismrt.com/# ">cialis no persription</a> cialis for cheap cialis going generic https://cialismrt.com/

comment

legal to buy prescription drugs without prescription <a href=" https://canadapillsshop.com/# ">canadian online drugs</a> prescription drugs canada buy online

comment

ivermectin for demodex <a href=" https://stromectolca.com/# ">ivermectin pour on for dogs</a> ivermectin dog

comment

new ed drugs <a href=" https://edpillcanada.com/# ">best ed pills non prescription</a> male ed pills

comment

order prescriptions online without doctor <a href=" https://canadadrs.online/# ">prescription drugs without doctor approval</a> canadian pharmaceuticals online safe

comment

stromectol without a doctor prescription <a href=" https://stromectolive.com/# ">stromectol for humans for sale</a> stromectol

comment

buy viagra online canada <a href=" https://sildenafilmg.shop/# ">viagra from canada</a> viagra discount

comment

viagra without a doctor prescription <a href=" https://sildenafilmg.shop/# ">viagra 100mg price</a> viagra discount

comment

prescription for amoxicillin <a href=" https://amoxilforsale.best/# ">amoxicillin 500mg capsules</a> where can i get amoxicillin 500 mg

comment

generic clomiphene <a href=" https://clomidforsale.life/# ">clomid coupon</a> clomid online cheap

comment

ed medication https://erectionpills.best/ buy erection pills

comment

how long does ivermectin toxicity last in dogs https://stromectoltrust.com/ azelaic acid metronidazole ivermectin

comment

pig wormer ivermectin <a href=" https://stromectoltrust.com/# ">topical ivermectin for humans</a> how long is ivermectin effective

comment

buy prescription drugs without doctor <a href=" https://medrxfast.com/# ">amoxicillin without a doctor's prescription</a> - amoxicillin without a doctor's prescription

comment

thyrotoxicosis <a href=http://iverstromectol.com/>stromectol ivermectin for humans</a>

Leave a reply

You may also like
We asked multicultural communities how best to communicate COVID-19 advice. Here’s what they told us

Sokra...

We asked multicultural co...

Secrets of Leadership: Hitler and Churchill

Sokra...

Secrets of Leadership: Hi...