#DeepNostalgia – how animating portraits with AI is both bolstering and undoing historic painted lies
The AI family history app MyHeritage allows users to animate photographs from the past. Run a document through the app and it will seemingly bring it to life, making the subject’s eyes blink and look around. Many have been turning this technology on photographs and paintings of well-known historical figures.
By Laura Hood*
The accompanying hashtag #DeepNostalgia has flooded social media with the reanimated faces of Charles Darwin, George Washington, Marie Antoinette and more.
In a fast-developing technological landscape, deepfakes are becoming more and more commonplace. The term refers to images or videos of people in which their faces and voices have been digitally altered. While few would claim these subdued avatars are absolutely convincing, their uncanny tangibility can be compelling.
Of course, the artworks fed into the app are not themselves completely accurate representations of the people in them. Painters have their own ways of interpreting sitters, according to their own style. Historically, they also used certain techniques and composition elements to communicate a person’s status and power (or lack thereof). So when these artistic embellishments on the truth go through an app that appears to bring people to life, the painted lies can either travel with them or give way to new interpretations driven by modern ideas.
Artistic licence
Among the historical portraits to receive this treatment is that of King George III’s consort Queen Charlotte, painted in 1773 by the English artist Nathaniel Dance-Holland (1735-1811). The original work shows the queen in an elaborate blue and gold dress trimmed with ermine and posed with a crown and sceptre. Looking directly out of the canvas, the young and pretty queen smiles as she meets the eye of any onlooker. But the painting is far from an accurate representation of Queen Charlotte who was, in fact, considered quite ugly in her time.
Dance-Holland, whose other celebrity clients included the colonist Captain James Cook, set out to flatter Charlotte and present her according to the protocols of royal portraiture. Less concerned with accurately reproducing the subject on canvas, royal portraits most often looked to present the monarch and their family as the embodiment of power, with artists regularly inserting into the composition objects used to signal statehood, diplomacy, wealth and empire.
View the following link on Twitter to get a glimpse:
https://twitter.com/Adam_Crymble/status/1365719041709649922
We know that portraits can often be deceiving. Painters employed artistic license, showing historical figures to be better looking, more powerful or imposing than they were in real life. Several courtiers explicitly described Charlotte as “ugly”. The queen herself remarked in her final years:
The English people did not like me much, because I was not pretty; but the King was fond of driving a phaeton [open top carriage] in those days, and once he overturned me in a turnip-field, and that fall broke my nose. I think I was not quite so ugly after [that].
When treated through the MyHeritage app, Dance-Holland’s choices in representing the queen are perpetuated. The meanings and values of the 18th-century are extended beyond the canvas and given power and life in our own time. The painted lie becomes a modern, social-media-perpetuated truth. What would have been visible to an audience in the past – one which could decipher the complex messages of paintings and who were familiar with the queen’s true looks – is instead presented to modern onlookers as fact.
Lost faces
So deepfake technology that relies on artworks as its primary source risks replicating falsehoods in some cases. In other instances, however, the technology has worked to create new ways of looking at a painting. This is a way of looking which subverts contemporary bigoted notions, creating a different painting with a more modern outlook altogether.
https://twitter.com/PeterBrathwaite/status/1366700953240535040
Opera singer and broadcaster Peter Brathwaite has spent his time in lockdown re-enacting artworks and bringing historical Black portraiture to the attention of millions. He applied the MyHeritage app to a portrait of Adolf Ludvig Gustav Fredrik Albert Couschi (1747-1822).
Couschi was born into slavery in the West Indies and came to the royal court of Sweden, where he gained an extensive education and several courtly titles. Painted in 1775 by the Swedish artist Gustaf Lundberg, Couschi is depicted bedecked in feathers and a blue tunic. Placed in front of him is a chessboard set with black and white pieces, no doubt included to draw attention to the colour of his skin in contrast with the predominantly white court.
In the deepfake version, Couschi comes alive, his eyes looking beyond the bounds of the canvas and our modern screen to survey, we might imagine, his new surroundings. The elements of the painting that speak the loudest to his perceived difference, namely the chess pieces, are cropped out. Instead, we are presented with a new work, one more closely framed around Couschi’s face and concerned with foregrounding his presence and personality.
While the lie of Queen Charlotte’s beauty persists when her portrait by Dance-Holland is put through the app, Couschi’s status is recentered for modern onlookers and detached from the contemporary racist narrative painted into his portrait.
Certainly, the #DeepNostaliga hashtag has made visible many lesser-known, or “lost”, faces from the past - valuable recovery work when applied to historical subjects traditionally marginalised. Among those to stare back at us as we scroll are mathematician and computer scientist Alan Turing and 19th-century American Abolitionist Frederick Douglas. Although subjects have, thus far, been predominantly men, the start of Women’s History Month saw the expressive faces of Liliʻuokalani, the Hawaiian queen who ruled from 1891 to 1893, and Irish writer Maria Edgeworth among the figures to receive this treatment.
*Laura Hood is Politics Editor
Technology Arts Culture Science Artificial Intelligence
Comments (59)
Propecia 2022-08-23, 9mos ago
propecia cost <a href=" https://finasteride.top/# ">finasteride 1mg</a> buy propecia 5mg finasteride online bonus https://finasteride.top/ propecia discount
Tadalafil 2022-08-27, 9mos ago
canada tadalafil generic https://tadalafil.pro/ 5mg tadalafil generic
Lipitor 2022-09-03, 9mos ago
lipitor 20mg <a href=" https://lipitor.icu/# ">cost of lipitor 20 mg</a> lipitor 20 lipitor prices australia https://lipitor.icu/ prescription medication lipitor
Lisinopril 2022-09-04, 9mos ago
lisinopril 2.5 mg coupon <a href=" https://lisinopril.icu/# ">zestril 10mg price</a> lisinopril 2.5 mg for sale lisinopril 10 mg for sale without prescription https://lisinopril.icu/ buy lisinopril online usa
Stromectol 2022-09-05, 9mos ago
ivermectin injectable for dogs https://stromectol.pro/ 1 ivermectin dosage for dogs
Paxlovid 2022-09-07, 8mos ago
covid pill https://paxlovid.best/ paxlovid clinical trial
Paxlovid 2022-09-09, 8mos ago
covid pills <a href=" https://paxlovid.best/# ">cost of paxlovid</a> paxlovid ivermectin paxlovid zulassung https://paxlovid.best/ molnupiravir brand name
CanadaF 2022-09-10, 8mos ago
herbal substitutes for viagra <a href=" https://viagracanada.xyz/# ">how much does viagra cost at walmart</a> do you need a prescription for female viagra does viagra lower your blood pressure https://viagracanada.xyz/ get viagra prescription online
Stromectol 2022-09-13, 8mos ago
topical ivermectin https://stromectol1st.com/
Stromectol 2022-09-14, 8mos ago
ivermectin and alcohol https://stromectol1st.com/
Clomidk 2022-09-15, 8mos ago
generic clomiphene <a href=" https://clomid.pro/# ">clomid purchase</a> clomid generic name clomid buy online https://clomid.pro/ clomiphene generic
Canadarx 2022-09-16, 8mos ago
comfortis for dogs without vet prescription <a href=" https://24hr-pharmacy.top/# ">buy prescription drugs from canada cheap</a> the canadian drugstore buy prescription drugs https://24hr-pharmacy.top/ prescription drugs without doctor approval
Doxycycline 2022-09-17, 8mos ago
price of doxycycline <a href=" https://doxycycline.pro/# ">doxycycline prices</a> doxycycline hydrochloride 100mg doxycycline mono https://doxycycline.pro/ doxycycline pills
Sildenafil 2022-09-30, 8mos ago
sildenafil online free shipping https://buysildenafil.best/ sildenafil 20mg online prescription
rlbjvek 2022-10-04, 8mos ago
4OVQkw <a href="http://iykgjodduwqg.com/">iykgjodduwqg</a>, [url=http://mtoexjkibrkj.com/]mtoexjkibrkj[/url], [link=http://vvcebhcphkcg.com/]vvcebhcphkcg[/link], http://zpzykogxfgpu.com/
Zithromax 2022-10-08, 7mos ago
zithromax for sale cheap <a href=" https://zithromax.best/# ">buy zithromax without prescription online</a> zithromax 500mg price in india
Amoxil 2022-10-08, 7mos ago
amoxicillin 875 mg tablet <a href=" https://amoxil.best/# ">amoxicillin 500 tablet</a> buy amoxicillin 500mg capsules uk
CiproRx 2022-10-09, 7mos ago
cipro generic <a href=" https://cipro.pro/# ">buy cipro online canada</a> ciprofloxacin generic
Doxycycline 2022-10-10, 7mos ago
generic doxycycline <a href=" https://buydoxycycline.icu/# ">doxycycline 100mg online</a> purchase doxycycline online
Antibiotic 2022-10-10, 7mos ago
bactrim without prescription <a href=" https://antibiotic.best/# ">zithromax prescription in canada</a> doxycycline without a prescription
Antibiotic 2022-10-11, 7mos ago
zithromax online usa no prescription <a href=" https://antibiotic.best/# ">buy amoxicillin without prescription</a> buy zithromax no prescription
Antibiotic 2022-10-11, 7mos ago
zithromax prescription online <a href=" https://antibiotic.best/# ">zithromax prescription</a> amoxicillin 500mg without prescription
Antibiotic 2022-10-11, 7mos ago
bactrim without prescription <a href=" https://antibiotic.best/# ">order zithromax without prescription</a> cost of amoxicillin prescription
Antibiotic 2022-10-11, 7mos ago
doxycycline without prescription <a href=" https://antibiotic.best/# ">zithromax for sale cheap</a> how much is amoxicillin prescription
Antibiotic 2022-10-11, 7mos ago
amoxicillin 500 mg without a prescription <a href=" https://antibiotic.best/# ">zithromax prescription in canada</a> buy cheap amoxicillin online
Doxycycline 2022-10-11, 7mos ago
doxycycline mono <a href=" https://buydoxycycline.icu/# ">doxycycline generic</a> buy cheap doxycycline online
Doxycycline 2022-10-11, 7mos ago
doxycycline 50 mg <a href=" https://buydoxycycline.icu/# ">buy doxycycline for dogs</a> doxy
Doxycycline 2022-10-11, 7mos ago
doxycycline 100mg tablets <a href=" https://buydoxycycline.icu/# ">buy cheap doxycycline</a> 200 mg doxycycline
Doxycycline 2022-10-11, 7mos ago
purchase doxycycline online <a href=" https://buydoxycycline.icu/# ">doxycycline 150 mg</a> doxycycline 150 mg
Doxycycline 2022-10-11, 7mos ago
doxycycline tablets <a href=" https://buydoxycycline.icu/# ">doxylin</a> doxycycline 100mg dogs
Doxycycline 2022-10-11, 7mos ago
where can i get doxycycline <a href=" https://buydoxycycline.icu/# ">buy doxycycline online 270 tabs</a> doxycycline 100mg dogs
Doxycycline 2022-10-11, 7mos ago
where to purchase doxycycline <a href=" https://buydoxycycline.icu/# ">buy doxycycline online uk</a> 100mg doxycycline
Ciprop 2022-10-11, 7mos ago
cipro for sale <a href=" https://cipro.pro/# ">ciprofloxacin 500 mg tablet price</a> ciprofloxacin
Ciprop 2022-10-11, 7mos ago
cipro pharmacy <a href=" https://cipro.pro/# ">ciprofloxacin generic</a> ciprofloxacin generic
Ciprop 2022-10-11, 7mos ago
where can i buy cipro online <a href=" https://cipro.pro/# ">buy cipro online canada</a> ciprofloxacin
Ciprop 2022-10-11, 7mos ago
ciprofloxacin generic price <a href=" https://cipro.pro/# ">cipro generic</a> cipro for sale
Ciprop 2022-10-11, 7mos ago
cipro for sale <a href=" https://cipro.pro/# ">ciprofloxacin over the counter</a> cipro
Ciprop 2022-10-11, 7mos ago
ciprofloxacin mail online <a href=" https://cipro.pro/# ">ciprofloxacin generic price</a> where can i buy cipro online
Ciprop 2022-10-11, 7mos ago
antibiotics cipro <a href=" https://cipro.pro/# ">buy cipro</a> cipro online no prescription in the usa
Amoxil 2022-10-11, 7mos ago
price of amoxicillin without insurance <a href=" https://amoxil.best/# ">buy amoxicillin 500mg usa</a> over the counter amoxicillin canada
Amoxil 2022-10-11, 7mos ago
prescription for amoxicillin <a href=" https://amoxil.best/# ">cheap amoxicillin 500mg</a> amoxicillin order online no prescription
Amoxil 2022-10-11, 7mos ago
amoxicillin online pharmacy <a href=" https://amoxil.best/# ">buy amoxicillin 500mg online</a> amoxicillin online canada
Amoxil 2022-10-11, 7mos ago
can i buy amoxicillin over the counter in australia <a href=" https://amoxil.best/# ">amoxicillin 500mg price in canada</a> amoxicillin pills 500 mg
Amoxil 2022-10-11, 7mos ago
amoxicillin online purchase <a href=" https://amoxil.best/# ">amoxicillin order online</a> rexall pharmacy amoxicillin 500mg
Amoxil 2022-10-11, 7mos ago
amoxicillin without a prescription <a href=" https://amoxil.best/# ">where to buy amoxicillin 500mg</a> amoxicillin 500mg prescription
Zithromax 2022-10-11, 7mos ago
zithromax capsules price <a href=" https://zithromax.best/# ">zithromax over the counter</a> where can i get zithromax
Zithromax 2022-10-11, 7mos ago
generic zithromax over the counter <a href=" https://zithromax.best/# ">zithromax drug</a> buy zithromax 500mg online
Pharmacy 2022-10-14, 7mos ago
canadian pharmacy world coupon https://pharmacywithoutprescription.life/
Pharmacy 2022-10-14, 7mos ago
canadian pharmacy coupon code https://pharmacywithoutprescription.life/
Dating 2022-10-17, 7mos ago
skip the game dating site free search <a href=" https://datingtopreview.com/# ">personals dating</a> single women online dating sinulator online https://datingtopreview.com/ meet single women
Clomid 2022-10-29, 7mos ago
<a href=" https://clomiphenecitrate.pro/# "></a> https://clomiphenecitrate.pro/
Sildenafil 2022-11-13, 6mos ago
can i buy sildenafil in canada https://sildenafilcitrate100mg.store/
Prednisone 2022-11-15, 6mos ago
where to get prednisone <a href=" https://prednisone20mg.site/# ">prednisone brand name us</a> prednisone 1 tablet
Prednisone 2022-11-15, 6mos ago
how much is prednisone 10mg <a href=" https://prednisone20mg.site/# ">50 mg prednisone canada pharmacy</a> can i purchase prednisone without a prescription
Pillsop 2022-12-10, 5mos ago
erectile dysfunction medicines https://cheapestedpills.shop/ best ed pills online
Pillsop 2022-12-10, 5mos ago
top ed drugs https://cheapestedpills.shop/ ed treatment review
CanadaRx 2023-03-15, 2mos ago
my canadian pharmacy rx: <a href=" https://canadaph.top/# ">safe reliable canadian pharmacy</a> canadian pharmacy com escrow pharmacy canada - https://canadaph.top/#
Erroppy 2023-03-17, 2mos ago
Aiden, USA 2022 05 28 16 20 21 <a href=https://buycialis.homes>36 hour cialis online</a>
Revecrype 2023-05-10, 3w ago
Some children with ADD ADHD have salicylate sensitivity <a href=http://cialiss.top>cialis 40 mg</a>